Go back

Bank to basics – Banker’s top 1000 shows tough regulation pays dividends

The full extent of the carnage in the global banking system is evident in the 2009 Top 1000 rankings due to be unveiled in The Banker magazine’s July issue. The Royal Bank of Scotland shows the worst losses in the world at $59.3 billion ahead of two American banks, Citigroup and Wells Fargo. The UK’s HBOS ranked sixth among the biggest losers.

Running since the 1970s, The Banker’s Top 1000 is an annual industry benchmark listing banks by their capital strength. Overall the banks in the Top 1000 had an abysmal year. System profits fell 85.3% from $780.8 billion to $115 billion and return on equity dropped from 20% to 2.69%.

Banks that stuck to the basics of banking, taking deposits and lending in their home markets, fare the best. Industrial and Commercial Bank of China followed by China Construction Bank and Spain’s Santander achieved the largest profits.

“These banks stuck to the basics of banking and did not get involved in some of the more complicated and highly leveraged financial instruments that caused so much damage at banks like Citigroup, Royal Bank of Scotland and UBS,” said The Banker’s editor Brian Caplen. “In the case of Spain they were helped to do so by the strictures of a tough national regulator.”

“In future banks will be run much more conservatively. Regulators will require them to hold more capital and be less leveraged. This will reduce the profits of the industry as a whole but will bring about a safer banking system.”

With banks having recapitalised over the past year, often with government support, the Top 1000 list shows that the international banking structure – dominated by Western banks with a handful of Japanese and Chinese players – remains relatively stable. JP Morgan, up from fourth last year, followed by Bank of America, Citigroup, Royal Bank of Scotland and HSBC which is the only one of the top five not to have received any government support.

If government support is removed from the ranking HSBC would be in third place, Royal Bank of Scotland falls to seventh while Japan’s Mitsubishi UFJ moves from 7 to 4 and Industrial and Commercial Bank of China goes from 8 to 5.

Consolidation in the banking sector brought about by the crisis has also impacted the rankings. JP Morgan’s takeover of Bear Stearns and Washington Mutual allowed it to climb into top position, Bank of America’s acquisition of Merrill Lynch pushed it to second and Wells Fargo’s acquisition of Wachovia allowed it to jump from 23 to sixth place. Lloyds and HBOS officially combined too late for the ranking but would have come in 16th just behind Barclays on consolidated numbers.

2009 has also seen the stand-alone investment bank become extinct. Investment banks are not included in the Top 1000 but during the crisis leading Wall Street banks converted to bank holding companies as a form of protection. As a result Goldman Sachs enters the ranking at number 13 and Morgan Stanley at number 17.

- ends -

For further information and to obtain ranking tables please contact:

Niki Wheeler, Launch Group, +44 (0) 207 758 3913 or nikiw@launchgroup.co.uk
Kristina Eriksson, Financial Times, +44 (0) 207 873 4961 or kristina.eriksson@ft.com

About The Banker:

The Banker was established in 1926 and is part of the Financial Times Group. The magazine has been carrying ranking since 1970 and also offers a database service. For more information about the ranking and the database go to www.thebanker.com/top1000.php and www.thebanker-database.co.uk.

Brian Caplen has been a financial and business journalist for 25 years He has worked in Hong Kong and the Middle East and reported from all over the world. He joined The Banker in 2000 and became editor in 2003.

About the Financial Times:

The Financial Times, one of the world’s leading business news organisations, is recognised internationally for its authority, integrity and accuracy. Providing extensive news, comment and analysis, the newspaper is printed at 23 print sites across the globe, has a daily circulation of 410,928 (ABC figures, May, 2009) and a readership of 1.3 million people worldwide. FT.com is the definitive home for business intelligence on the web, providing an essential source of news, comment, data and analysis for the global business community. FT.com attracts 11.4 million unique users, generating 83.2 million page views (ABCe figures, March 2009) and now has over 1.2 million registered users.

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2011. You may share using our article tools. Please don’t cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web.

Back to top